|
¶4 On March 5, 2014, the OLR filed a
complaint against Attorney Isaacson alleging
four counts of professional misconduct.
James Curtis was appointed referee.
Attorney Isaacson never filed an answer and
did not appear in the action. The OLR filed
a motion for default judgment on August 6,
2014. The record reflects that, despite
multiple and extensive efforts to provide
Attorney Isaacson with notice of the default
hearing, all efforts to contact Attorney
Isaacson were unsuccessful.
¶5 The referee found that Attorney
Isaacson was properly served with an
authenticated copy of the complaint and
order to answer pursuant to the provisions
of SCR 22.13(1), ruled that all of the
allegations of the complaint were deemed
established to the standard of clear,
satisfactory, and convincing evidence, and
granted the OLR's motion for default
judgment on October 20, 2014. On November
24, 2014, the referee filed a report and
recommendation addressing sanctions.
¶6 The disciplinary complaint alleges
violations of both the Wisconsin Rules of
Professional Conduct for Attorneys and the
Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct
(MRPC).
¶7 First, we note that Attorney
Isaacson is not alleged to have acted as an
attorney in this disciplinary proceeding.
Rather, she is a licensed Wisconsin attorney
who engaged in misconduct while serving in
the capacity as an officer or managing
member of a corporate entity and its
subsidiaries. Specifically, Attorney
Isaacson was the Chief Executive Officer of
Dr. R. C. Samanta Roy Institute of Science
and Technology, Inc., known as "SIST,"
together with its wholly owned subsidiaries
and limited liability companies. The
complaint identifies several somewhat
interrelated litigation proceedings in which
Attorney Isaacson participated. She
prepared and signed affidavits,
declarations, or responses in these matters
which were filed on her behalf. The core of
the complaint is that Attorney Isaacson's
statements in these documents had no
apparent purpose other than to harass
judicial officers, public officials,
opposing counsel, and others based on race,
creed, and religion.
¶8 As the referee observed, it is
difficult to summarize the verbose and
grandiose allegations leveled by Attorney
Isaacson against the courts generally,
specific judges, other counsel, appointed
officers, and third parties. The OLR's
complaint contains over 70 paragraphs
providing detailed context for and quoting
from specific sworn and verified statements
she made in court filings. A few examples
must suffice to convey the nature of
Attorney Isaacson's statements.
¶9 Some of the entities with which
Attorney Isaacson is affiliated were
involved in a public amusement go—cart track
business in Shawano, Wisconsin. In the mid—
2000s, creditors of the go—cart track
business alleged default and brought claims
against various corporate entities. In
2009, USAO and SIST filed for Chapter 11
bankruptcy protection in the U.S. Bankruptcy
Court for the District of Delaware. The
cases were administered together with the
simultaneous bankruptcy filings of five
other wholly owned subsidiaries of SIST. On
September 22, 2009, these bankruptcy
proceedings were dismissed.
¶10 On May 28, 2010, one of the
aforementioned creditors, Southwest
Guaranty, Ltd., successfully moved to reopen
proceedings in Shawano County, Wisconsin.
On July 13, 2010, Midwest Properties of
Shawano, LLC filed for Chapter 11
bankruptcy. In re Midwest Properties of
Shawano, LLC, Case No. 10-31515 (Bankr.
E.D. Wis.).
¶11 On July 16, 2010, Attorney Isaacson
drafted and signed a sworn affidavit filed
in the Midwest Properties bankruptcy case.
Attorney Isaacson's affidavit stated, inter
alia, that the Shawano Mayor "has wrapped
her tentacles around the judiciary system
including Shawano Municipal judges, Shawano
County judges, Wisconsin Appellate Court
judges, the Federal District Court judge in
Green Bay, Seventh Circuit Appellate Court
judges, and even [the U.S. Bankruptcy Court
Judge in Delaware]."
¶12 On August 15, 2010, Attorney
Isaacson personally prepared and signed a
declaration that was filed in Southwest
Guaranty, Ltd. v. U.S. Acquisitions & Oil,
Inc., et al., Case No. 10-CV-596 (E.D.
Wis.). In that declaration, she stated
that "Shawano is Neo-Nazi territory where it
is believed people of other races and
religions have no right to life," and
referred to the "underlying White
Supremacist feelings and beliefs and Jim
Crow mentality held by many persons in
Shawano." She declared that the "[d]
efendant's experience of 'justice' in
Shawano is comparable to the 'justice' Jews
experienced under Hitler's regime."
¶13 On October 12, 2010, in a written
order and decision, the U.S. District Court
remanded the USAO case to the Shawano County
Circuit Court and agreed to impose sanctions
for what the court described as "a number of
inflammatory and irrelevant allegations
regarding Southwest Guaranty, their counsel,
and various members of the Shawano
community." The court observed
that "inexplicably" the matter "includes a
number of detailed, serious, and bizarre
allegations in the footnotes about certain
members of the Shawano community, including
judges, city officials, and the mayor of
Shawano." The court observed that "[t]he
objectionable allegations are so fantastic
and delusional that no reasonable attorney
would certify that they have evidentiary
support."
¶14 Attorney Isaacson was also involved
with bankruptcy proceedings pending in
Minnesota and similar documents were filed
in those proceedings. On August 17, 2010,
Attorney Isaacson signed a declaration filed
in In re Midwest Oil of Minnesota, LLC,
Case No. 10—35450 (Bankr. D. Minn.), in
which she stated that "[the Shawano Mayor]
is involved in sending her cultic
missionaries to other lands to destroy the
family values, heritages, and cultures that
have preserved peoples of other
civilizations for thousands of years" and
declared that the mayor "is a member of the
most dangerous, dirtiest, and deadliest
death cult in human history and is a
descendent of Martin Luther and Hitler who
started and propagated the Lutheran cult."
Attorney Isaacson also referred to the
bankruptcy trustee as "a visceral racist,"
an "ignoramus," and "a member of this most
dangerous, dirtiest, and deadliest death
cult in human history as well."
¶15 On August 18, 2010, at a hearing on
the trustee's motion to dismiss the Midwest
Oil case, the presiding bankruptcy judge
commented on the pleadings, which included
an Attorney Isaacson document, "which in my
time on the bench are among the worst and
most scurrlious [sic], defamatory pleadings
I have ever seen from a lawyer."
¶16 On March 23, 2011, Yehud—Monosson
USA, Inc. filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in
the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern
District of New York, Case No. 11-11278. On
April 12, 2011, Attorney Isaacson drafted
and signed a sworn affidavit in which she
averred that "[t]rying a matter in Minnesota
is like sending the Jews back to Germany
during the Holocaust."
¶17 On April 13, 2011, over the debtor's
objections, the Yehud-Monosson bankruptcy
was transferred from New York to Minnesota
and converted to a Chapter 7 proceeding. On
October 19, 2011, Attorney Isaacson signed a
sworn affidavit that was filed with the
court in which she stated that the
bankruptcy trustee was making false,
defamatory, scandalous, and misleading
statements to the court. Eventually,
contempt proceedings were brought against
Attorney Isaacson, and on November 10, 2011,
Attorney Isaacson swore to and signed an
affidavit in which she claimed that the
trustee "lied to the court" and "persisted
in her perjurious conduct," and stated
that "[o]bviously, like her dirty bible,
[the trustee] is full of lies and deceit."
¶18 Attorney Isaacson made reference to
trustees, variously, as a "dirty Catholic
inquisitor," a "Jesuitess," and a "priest's
boy," and referred to various judges as
a "black-robed bigot," a "Jesuit judge," and
a "Catholic Knight Witch Hunter." She
stated that court systems, "particularly the
Bankruptcy Court in Minnesota, are composed
of a bunch of ignoramus, bigoted Catholic
beasts that carry the sword of the church."
¶19 At an ensuing hearing on November
29, 2011, the presiding judge described
Attorney Isaacson's language
as "irresponsible, unprofessional and
unbelievably and unmitigatingly outrageous".
¶20 Attorney Isaacson responded with a
second declaration in which she repeated
similar rhetoric and referred to the Chapter
7 trustee as the court's "Inquisitor."
Then, on December 30, 2011, Attorney
Isaacson signed a 17—page "response" in
which she expressly asserted that all her
statements as quoted by the court were true
and accurate and not made for any improper
purpose. She referred to the first
bankruptcy judge to hear the case in
Minnesota as "an avowed Jesuit," "the dirty
Jesuit," a "dastardly Jesuit," and "a Jesuit
working undercover." Attorney
Isaacson's "response" also included
statements such as "out of personal malice,
[the court] has issued this Order to Show
Cause and warrant for my arrest," and "[s]
ince the unfortunate day that [the trustee]
was appointed, she has been a Jesuitess,
meaning a zealous advocate of her bigoted
catholic White Supremacy beliefs."
¶21 Eventually, Attorney Isaacson was
held in contempt for failing to comply with
the orders to turn over documents and
information and for her failures to appear
on before the court. The U.S. Bankruptcy
Court issued an order for sanctions against
Attorney Isaacson "for each of the
sanctionable statements identified in the
court's order to show cause." Attorney
Isaacson appealed and the Eighth Circuit
Court of Appeals affirmed. Isaacson v.
Manty, 721 F.3d 533 (8th Cir. 2013).
¶22 The referee concluded, as to Count
One, that the undisputed allegations of the
complaint establish clear, satisfactory, and
convincing evidence that:
|
|